Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jason Hubbard's avatar

I think that a thing that is missed for non-Wasians is the way that Wasians are othered by both sets of their heritage. In the US, a mixed race black person is black and accepted as such by the black community, by and large (as an outsider, I still see conflict for people of mixed heritage in the black community; I have mixed race black cousins through the white side of my family). A mixed race latino/hispanic kid is similarly also latino/hispanic, maybe even more so than a mixed race black person gains access to being authentically 'black.'

For mixed race Asians, this is not the case.

The first layer of that onion is that even for east Asians, 'Asian' is more of a fake label. East Asians generally do not think of themselves as 'Asian' anymore than white Europeans really think of themselves as 'white,' they think of themselves as coded by their ethnic homeland. For that matter, to my observation Africans in Africa generally do not think of themselves as 'black,' and recognize several African ethnicities. So in the Asian case like a Han Chinese person from Singapore still thinks of themselves as 'Chinese' by ethnicity and often culture, distinct from 'Malay' or 'Indonesian.' There is not really a shared heritage, or even a shared narrative of colonization. Like a lot of Hispanic/Latino culture is downstream of Spanish or Portuguese conquest of the Americas, and similarities between Spanish and Portuguese heritage and culture.

But even within these nationality identities, mixed race children do not get access to that identity culture the way that mixed race people of other ethnicities do in the US. Asia is still pretty rampant with it's own ethnic and racial prejudice, so even within these national ethnic identities there is prejudice and insularity. In Japan, a person of half-Korean descent is still seen as primarily Korean, this goes for China too. Asian ethnicities work much the same as whiteness does in the US, if you have foreign blood then you are foreign first, at BEST a half-step closer from foreign.

So to be Wasian is to be considered 'foreign' to your Asian ethnic heritage, and 'not White' to your white heritage, because Whiteness always selects against those who are not 'white enough,' and this is covered plenty for mixed race people of other races. You have to be visually 'white passing' to get white privilege in the US.

It's also othering in exactly the way you are demonstrating here, which is that to non-white people of other races, we are always under suspicion of being 'too white,' suspected of having some sort of surrogate white privilege. Black and Latinos make exceptions for mixed race people of their own ethnicity, but suspect white privilege when it is mixed race people of other ethnicities.

So these three alienations really leave us permanently Other, without an ethnic community to call home. We are foreign to our Asian ancestry, not white enough for our white ancestry, too white for the larger community of color. It's a culturally homeless state.

Al S. Brown's avatar

I really liked this line:

"But mestizaje is a century-long case study in what happens when “confusing the racists” becomes the whole strategy. White supremacy is remarkably good at absorbing confusion. It simply redraws the line a few shades lighter and keeps going."

Thanks for the history lesson. I learned some things about past movements, as well as the Wasian identity.

And double-thanks for the reminder that white supremacists will have no problem maintaining their world view in the face of all this!!

30 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?